Umbrella Academy Ramblings (Spoilers)
Mar. 10th, 2019 08:54 pm I think the Luther/Allison relationship is troubling for a lot of reasons, not anything to do with 'too much' focus on romance, which I don't think is overly much of a concern in the show, although I do think the 'lonely girl falls for evil dude because he's the only one who will pay attention to her' is a pretty sexist trope when, like, a sympathetic friend would have highlighted even more of the show's themes and been better character development. I do think the show focused too much on Luther altogether, because he's very boring and I don't think the show would've suffered if he'd simply been written out of it. Anyway, the problems are as follows:
- social myth: men and women aren't capable of being platonic friends, and must always have sexual tension
- social myth: men and women of different races aren't capable of being platonic friends
- social myth: men being attracted to women/women being attracted to men is normal and expected even in taboo circumstances, other types of attraction would not occur under taboo circumstances even if otherwise available
- social myth: adopted families aren't real families and adopted siblings aren't really related
- social myth: people of the same race can be 'real families' if they're adopted, but people of different races can't
- social myth: woc are attracted to the strength and virility of white men and can't help but become romantically obsessed
- social myth: woc are more likely to engage in obscene/perverse/taboo sexual and romantic relationships, esp. can't tell
- social myth: poc can't have familial relationships and don't understand familial love
- social myth: everyone wants and seeks out romance in any life circumstance
- pseudoscientific myth: people of 'different races' aren't as genetically related and don't have to worry about recessive disorders
- pseudoscientific myth: people of 'different races' don't form familial bonds during childhood/can 'just tell' they 'aren't the same'
- uncomfortable narrative trope: people don't change over time and knowing someone once means being able to accurately predict their behavior forever, even after a period of several years with little to no contact
- uncomfortable narrative trope: being in love once means being in love forever/feelings can't and don't change
- uncomfortable narrative trope: abuse makes people incapable of observing social taboos/insulates them from fallout
- uncomfortable narrative trope: woc (especially black woman) has a large part of her personality, motivation, or plot arc defined by relationship to white man, especially romantic relationship
- uncomfortable narrative trope: woc 'behaves better' or is more moral when in romantic relationship with white man
- uncomfortable narrative trope: woc can't be important character unless in a relationship that subordinates her to a more important part of the story, woc defined by relationship to team leader
- uncomfortable narrative trope: man defined by physical strength must seek out strong and masculine woman to be his equal partner in romance, combined with social myth: black women are masculine, social myth: black women are more physical than other women
- uncomfortable narrative trope: love heals, love conquers all
- uncomfortable narrative trope: people, especially women, are mostly concerned over romance instead of the world ending